Where to Find the Best Pizza in Ashtabula, Ohio

Craving a slice of bubbling mozzarella and tangy tomato sauce? You don’t have to make a trip to Chicago or New York City to graze on the tasty pizza—discover the best pizza in Ashtabula, Ohio. Our Italian roots run deep in Northeast Ohio. Combine your favorite vino with a local pie for a restful night in Ohio’s wine valley. Find more Geneva-on-the-Lake recommendations in our exclusive Vacation Guide!

Download Your Vacation Guide

Seven Pizza Spots in Ashtabula That Will Have You Singing “That’s Amore!”

Main Street Pizza

It may look like your typical mom-and-pop pizza shop from the outside, but it’s so much more than that. Main Street Pizza crafts hand-tossed dough, smothered in their homemade marinara sauce and generously finished with your choice of toppings. Baked to crispy perfection, Main Street’s pizza checks all of our boxes—friendly, affordable, and delicious.

Luigi’s Pizza & Wings

Pizza goes with wings like peanut butter with jelly, and the folks at Luigi’s Pizza know how to do it right. The restaurant offers 14 uniquely flavored wings including Sriracha ranch, sweet chili, and everything in between. Their pies are covered in traditional, sweet tomato sauce and baked with as many toppings as your pizza-shaped heart desires.

Looking for something on the go? Try their pepperoni twists—fresh pepperoni, rolled into their homemade pizza dough and brushed with Luigi’s signature garlic sauce.

Covered Bridge Pizza Parlor

Covered Bridge Pizza has all of Ashtabula’s distinctively crafted pizza pies. Their garlic pizza is essentially buttery, garlic smothered bread on top of a thin crust pizza. Taco pizza is covered with cumin-spiced ground beef and topped with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and black olives. The BLT pizza is one of Chef Bob’s newest creations. It’s similar to its sister sandwich—smothered with pan-fried bacon, crispy lettuce, and a juicy tomato.

JD’s Pizza

If you need to feed the masses, you need to visit JD’s Pizza. JD’s is the only pizza place in town that can provide an entire sheet of pizza! That’s 48 square-cut slices of melt-in-your-mouth piatzza. Choose a few of their 19 premium toppings and baking preferences, and you’ll be singing about the pie in the sky for the next week.

Capos Pizza

If you’re searching for a flavor-filled, hearty grinder, look no further than Capos. The Italian sausage sub is a local favorite, but we also recommend the meatball sub and the hot ham and cheese.

Their pizza is nothing to breeze over either. Capos caters to all appetites with their personalized Italian bread pizza to a generous, 16-inch, “everything” pizza. Before you leave, check out their craft beer carry-out section and design your custom six-pack.  

Are you in Geneva? Check out their location near The Lakehouse Inn!

Purola’s BSP

Purola’s Bridge Street Pizza affords the ideal spot to get your “Lady and the Tramp” date night on. Locals harp over their massive calzones or share an order of spaghetti and meatballs. We recommend diving into the Tour of Italy pizza. It’s made-to-order with finely chopped pepperoni and meatballs, fresh bruschetta tomatoes, sweet onions, creamy ricotta, shaved parmesan, basil, red pepper flakes, and brushed with EVOO.

Salvatos Pizza   

Salvatos has been a neighborhood favorite for decades. You can count on them for consistently fresh ingredients, tasty housemade sauce, and a welcoming staff. The menu is about what you would expect from your local pizza shop, but the flavor is unparalleled. Be sure to get your order in before 8:30, however, because the establishment closes at 9 p.m. Salvatos is the kind of place where if you order more than once and they know you by name—it’s as genuine as it gets.   

Roll Yourself Back to The Lakehouse Inn!

Sunset Suite The Lakehouse InnWhen you’ve finished your Ashtabula pizza tour, waddle back to the Sunset Suite at The Lakehouse Inn! The luxurious room is complete with a queen bed, two-person whirlpool, electric fireplace, and kitchenette (with a microwave for heating leftovers). Book our cooling, summertime Twisted Raspberry Tea pedicure and manicure and get comfortable by the lake. Explore more of Ashtabula with our list of recommendations for roaming Bridge Street. Check our availability today!